All / Quick View Cute Vintage Penguin Toothpick Holder $10.00 Quick View EAPG Heisey Custard Glass Winged Scroll Toothpick Holder - 1899 $40.00 Quick View Vintage Indiana McCoy Pottery Cat - 1950s $12.00 Quick View Fenton Hobnail Art Glass Amber Toothpick Holder – Diamond Point Pattern $12.00 Quick View Vintage - Mid Century Modern Fish Toothpick Appetizer Holder - Anthropomorphic $24.00 Quick View White Porcelain Double-Headed Match Holder $15.00 Quick View 1990 Fitz & Floyd Pansy Flower Napkin Holder Ceramic White Pink Yellow $20.00 Quick View Antique Crystal Toothpick Holder with Scroll/Caned Band - (1895-1900) $12.00 Quick View Nippon White Gold Trim Toothpick Cigarette Holder $22.00 Quick View Old Czechoslovakian 3 Handles Toothpick Holder $30.00 Quick View White Hammered Metal Napkin Ring with Inset of Abalone $10.00 Quick View Set of 5 Ivory-Colored Pyraline Napkin Holders – Vintage $30.00 Quick View White Pottery Angel Napkin Ring $5.00 Quick View Embossed Glass Jim Beam Bourbon Whiskey Horseshoe Toothpick Holder $10.00 Quick View White Milk Glass Hobnail Footed Toothpick Holder $12.00 Quick View Fenton White Milk Glass Footed Hobnail Toothpick Holder $18.00 Quick View Heavy Silver Napkin Ring with Shield $25.00 Quick View Heavy Sterling Napkin Ring $25.00 Quick View Plain Silver Hourglass Shaped Napkin Ring $23.00 Quick View 4 Leaded Crystal Napkin Rings $24.00 Quick View Urn Shaped Silver - plate Match, Cigarette or Toothpick Holder with Handles $15.00 Quick View Three White China Floral Napkin Rings $30.00 Quick View L. G. Wright Milk Glass Ruffled Vase with Cherry Pattern $20.00 Quick View Top Hat Toothpick Holder in Colbalt Blue $10.00 Quick View Fenton Green Toothpick Holder Daisy and Button Top Hat $10.00 Quick View 1887 Antique Colorado Crystal with Gold Toothpick Holder $35.00